Grist: “Federal court rules there is no constitutional right to safe drinking water,” by Adam Mahoney.
“Nearly all of the residents of Jackson have watched brackish, dirty, impure, + undrinkable water trickle from their taps…at times, some have had no water at all,” residents reported in 2022.
“Jackson residents did everything this country tells poor people to do…they organized, they testified, they boiled their water, they filed suit, they trusted the courts…at every step the answer has been no,” said Danyelle Holmes, a senior national organizer with Mississippi’s Poor People’s Campaign.
“A federal appeals court has used a decades-long water crisis in one of the Blackest cities in America to rule that the U.S. Constitution does not guarantee Americans the right to clean + safe drinking water.” Previously, the Environmental Protection Agency…determined that the city could not receive support through the Civil Rights Act of 1965.
“What is happening in Jackson matters because federal data show Black communities are more likely than white communities to be served by water systems with health-based Safe Drinking Water Act violations.” Research has also found that systems in communities with larger Black populations take much longer to be fixed or improved.
“The lawsuit that spurred the federal appeals court ruling was first brought by Jackson residents who alleged that city officials knowingly allowed lead-contaminated [+ other impurities] water to reach their homes + then misled the public about whether it was safe to drink.” The suit also alleged that state authorities violated civil rights law by repeatedly sending federal money earmarked for drinking water safety to white communities rather than Jackson.
“In the September 4 ruling, the Fifth U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals affirmed a lower court’s dismissal of the case.” Judge Kurt Engelhardt wrote that while access to safe water is “important,” it is not a right “deeply rooted in our Nation’s history and tradition,” the standard the court used to decide whether it is protected by the Constitution. Engelhardt also wrote “lying about the presence of lead in the water is a far cry from the state’s physically extracting evidence from a criminal suspect or conducting an invasive medical procedure without consent.”
Unadulterated racism, straight up.